Wednesday, July 31, 2013

Laid-off Plain Dealer staffers, half volunteers, half not, drink at Irish wake

Last night, after word went out that The Plain Dealer’s newsroom layoffs would come today, Ellen Jan Kleinerman stayed late to finish her article, knowing it might be her last.

At 8 p.m., the medical reporter scheduled her story to post on It went online this morning at 6 a.m. Four hours later, she and about 44 other journalists were out of a job.

“I was in mourning for my career, for my colleagues, and for journalism in general,” Kleinerman said tonight on the patio of the Market Garden Brewery, where dozens of Plain Dealer reporters gathered for what was dubbed an Irish wake. “The way we cover news is changing. I’m all for change, but I’m not sure I’m embracing the type of change that’s going to come.”

The Plain Dealer slashed its unionized newsroom staff by 30 percent today, part of its switch to a digital-first news strategy and its cutback to a four-day home delivery schedule next week.

About half of the laid-off journalists volunteered to go. Harlan Spector, head of the Newspaper Guild local, and John Mangels, leader of the union’s Save The Plain Dealer campaign, asked to be put on the layoff list. So did columnists Regina Brett and Margaret Bernstein.

For those who chose to leave, the layoff amounts to a generous buyout – a union-guaranteed two weeks’ pay for every year worked. It’s also a chance to save someone else’s job while opting out of Advance Publications’ digital future.

“I’ve been doing this a long time,” said Spector, a 32-year journalist and 23-year PD veteran, after the Guild’s 6 pm rally outside the Plain Dealer offices. “I never thought I’d leave the business. But the way things are going here, I didn’t think I’d get to practice journalism the way I and many others have practiced it.”

The new way is speed and clicks, not ink. Managers are telling PD reporters to think of themselves as working for a website, not a newspaper, one staffer said. While they post news as it happens, a new team of curators will decide which stories make it to print.

The changes concern Kleinerman, who says editors seem focused on attracting hits, not a story’s value to the community. She fears the PD’s remaining journalists won’t have time to chase unsexy stories that drive change, like her 2009 series about the Cleveland water division’s plague of broken meters, outrageous over-billing and hour-long call times.

“I’ve been in journalism 30 years,” she said. “I love writing. I love the mission. It’s very fulfilling when you do a story and you know that you’ve informed readers and changed lives.”

For 110 journalists and a few dozen nonunion editors, that work goes on. Today -- as if to signal the new regime will support in-depth projects -- previewed a digital-first investigative series on DNA testing of old rape kits. It’s set to debut Monday, the first day with no home-delivered Plain Dealer. Rachel Dissell, a reporter on the project, says some elements will also run in the paper, but a few, such as an interactive digital timeline, won’t fit a print format.

Tomorrow, and The Plain Dealer will cover Ariel Castro’s sentencing, the finale to the city’s biggest story of the year. It could be a morale boost for the slimmed-down staff – or, at least, a way to work through survivor’s guilt.


Renate Jakupca said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

As major cities like Cleveland became one party towns the press became cheerleaders instead of skeptical adversaries. Of the major corruption stories that brought down Democratic leaders in Cuyahoga County not one of them were broken by or caused by PD reporters. How many times was Gerald McFaul endorsed by the Plain Dealer?

They pissed away their responsibilities and now lament that there's no future for "journalism." I guess they never studied "irony" in all those writing classes in college.

Anonymous said...

Of course this story is getting lots of coverage. But what sadly got no coverage was the recent unjust layoff of all employees of THE CLEVELAND CITIZEN, a 150 year old labor newspaper. The paper is owned by the Cleveland Building and Construction Trades, which represents the building trades unions. Subscribers of the paper are trade union members. Employees of the paper were denied union membership, yet the paper had to be printed by union printers and advertising was carefully scrutinized to be sure they were using union labor if available. The employees were underpaid, getting much much less than union wages (a little above minimum wage), no health care, regular raises or other union benefits. They were let go after 10-15 years employment through no fault of their own, all because a company with union ties took over their jobs. They were deemed ineligible for unemployment and did not receive any severance pay. How's that for union hypocrisy? SHAME on the Building Trades and the unions who turned their heads.
WalMart (known for their anti-union stance and low wages) treats their employees better!

Anonymous said...

MSNBC is next..just like Air America ..liberal journalism is dead.

Erick Trickey said...

ejhill: Actually, Mark Puente's stories about McFaul took him down. The investigations of McFaul followed the paper's work.

See my 2009 story:

For The Record
Mark Puente’s 18 stories about former Cuyahoga County Sheriff Gerald McFaul’s office put the Plain Dealer police reporter on the front page and reminded the city that it still needs a watchdog.

Anonymous said...

of course some will say i was "volunteer layoff"-- if u know u r out the door why not save face and take severance? but no way do i think all these were "volunteer".

if u need job to pay bills or like your work, no one volunteers to lose job unless u know u r gonna be let go.

Plain Dealer profitable, but the beancounters run everything today--

this is serious blow to Greater Cleveland. Newhouse family and Cleveland civic leaders all should be ashamed to let this happen.

Income Protection Insurance Redundancy said...

Employers should prioritize providing their employees final benefits in case of a layoff.rldtbut